What Are The Differences between Linear Guides And Linear Shafts?

In the fields of mechanical manufacturing, automated equipment, and many others, guide rails play a crucial role in guiding and supporting movement, ensuring that moving parts can operate accurately and smoothly. Linear guide rails and linear shafts are the two most common types of guide rails, and this blog will analyze their differences.

1. Structural principles

1.1 linear guide

Linear guide rails typically consist of a rail, a slider, a reversing device, and balls or rollers. The slider moves linearly along the rail, with the balls or rollers inside rolling between the rail and the slider, converting sliding friction into rolling friction. For example, in ball linear guide rails, multiple high-precision balls are evenly distributed in the raceways of the slider and rail, bearing the load and facilitating smooth movement of the slider.

1.2 linear shaft

The structure of the linear shaft is relatively simple, mainly consisting of a plane guide rail with certain precision and a slider that matches it. The slider directly contacts the guide rail, generating sliding friction during movement. Lubricating oil is used to reduce the coefficient of friction, allowing the slider to move smoothly relative to the guide rail.

2. Friction characteristics

2.1 linear guide

Due to the use of rolling friction, the coefficient of friction is extremely small, generally between 0.001 and 0.005. This means that the force required to start is minimal, and the resistance during movement is also weak, allowing the equipment to quickly respond to commands, easily achieve high-speed and high-frequency reciprocating motion, and have low energy consumption, significantly reducing operating costs.

2.2 linear shaft

The coefficient of sliding friction is relatively high, approximately between 0.1 and 0.3. A significant static friction force needs to be overcome at startup, and even after movement begins, the dynamic friction force is not negligible. Therefore, the equipment starts relatively slowly, and when running at high speeds, friction generates noticeable heat, leading to high energy consumption and potential thermal deformation that may affect precision. However, it can still be used in low-speed, heavy-load conditions where speed response requirements are not high.

3. Accuracy maintenance

3.1 linear guide

Due to the uniform distribution of the rolling elements and high-precision manufacturing processes, the guiding accuracy of linear guides is extremely high, reaching micrometer or even sub-micrometer levels. Moreover, during long-term use, wear is relatively uniform. As long as regular maintenance and lubrication are performed, high precision can be maintained for extended periods, ensuring precise operation of equipment. Linear guides are the preferred choice for fields that demand high precision, such as precision machine tools and semiconductor manufacturing equipment.

3.2 linear shaft

Initial precision depends on the machining accuracy of the guide rail and slider. At the beginning of use, it can meet certain precision requirements. However, as usage continues, uneven wear caused by sliding friction can lead to issues such as local scratches and pulling injuries, causing a rapid decline in precision. Frequent adjustments to the clearance and re-scraping of the guide rail surface are needed to restore precision, resulting in high maintenance costs. Nevertheless, it can still meet basic requirements for some rough machining equipment or devices that are not sensitive to dynamic changes in precision.

4. Load capacity

4.1 linear guide

Its load capacity is mainly determined by the size, number, and specification of the balls or rollers. Generally, small linear guides are suitable for light loads, while large linear guides with multiple balls (rollers) can withstand greater radial and axial loads, and can even be combined to handle complex forces, such as when an industrial robotic arm picks up heavy objects and moves them flexibly, the linear guides steadily bear forces from all directions.

4.2 linear shaft

Due to its large contact area, the linear shaft has excellent heavy-load capacity, especially excelling in withstanding vertical downward pressure. It is commonly used in the worktables of heavy-duty machine tools and large stamping equipment, providing solid support for large and heavy moving parts, ensuring smooth and stable operation without shaking.

5. Installation and maintenance

5.1 linear guide

Installation is relatively simple, as the rails and sliders usually have standard specifications, with precise mounting holes provided. Just follow the manual and use the appropriate tools to quickly complete the installation. Routine maintenance mainly involves regularly cleaning impurities from the surface of the rails and sliders, timely replenishing lubricating grease, and if a ball or roller is damaged, it can also be conveniently replaced under professional guidance, without needing to disassemble the entire rail system.

5.2 linear shaft

The installation requires stringent alignment of the rails, both horizontally and vertically, necessitating precise adjustments to ensure smooth movement of the slider. Maintenance is labor-intensive, requiring frequent lubrication and careful monitoring of oil film thickness and uniformity to prevent dry friction. If the rail surface wears out, the repair process is complex, often involving re-grinding and scraping of the rail surface, which is time-consuming and demanding on the technical skills of the maintenance personnel.

6. Cost comparison

6.1 linear guide

The initial procurement costs are high due to its precise manufacturing process, high-precision components, and complex structural design, which makes the price relatively high. However, when considering long-term operation, maintenance, and precision assurance comprehensively, it has significant overall cost-effectiveness advantages in high-precision and high-efficiency production scenarios because of its low energy consumption, convenient maintenance, and long lifespan.

6.2 linear shaft

The structure is simple, with low material and processing costs, resulting in lower procurement prices and minimal initial investment. However, due to high energy consumption, frequent maintenance, replacement of wear parts, and costs for precision restoration, the total long-term cost may gradually increase. It is suitable for equipment applications with limited budgets and relatively rough operating conditions.

In summary, linear guides and linear shafts each have their own advantages and disadvantages. When selecting in practice, it is necessary to weigh the pros and cons based on multiple factors such as the precision requirements of the equipment, load characteristics, operating speed, budget cost, and maintenance capabilities, to choose the most suitable type of guide, ensuring the equipment operates at its best state.

Welcome to contact us for more information!